Welcome

NOTICE: I have decided to put a hold on this blog page until further notice. No new comments will be allowed. The content will remain, but no new posts will be included. Please go to the alternate site to comment, discuss or debate:



This is a blog for discussions and debates regarding Faith and Reason.

Please be respectful, polite, use proper language, no profanity, stick to the topic discussion, no circular argumentation or fallacious reasoning, and avoid personal attacks/ad hominem.

All posts and original content are copyright Sacerdotus/Rationally Faithful. Whatever you post becomes property of this blog.

Please ask for permission before using any content and if permission is given, provide credit to the author, do not alter the content and backlink to the original post.

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

Why do Atheists Care about God?




  • Atheism is a belief that there is no God/never was one.  
  • Despite this bold claim, Atheists are still fixated on God.  This is interesting because let's say: 
  1. Person A does not like carrots and Person B does.  
  2. Being that Person A despises carrots he/she will not even contemplate it; whereas Person B loves carrots and will contemplate them.  


So why do Atheists care about a being that does not exist, is fictional - a myth?  

Why waste cognitive resources contemplating a supposed figment of the imagination?  

13 comments:

  1. Basically atheism is a voice of reality in an age where superstition has ruled for ages. If the belief in imaginary gods and other superstitions were to stop, humankind would benefit. Less war, and less bigotry.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What reality? Reality is just electrical impulses interpreted by the brain. Where is your evidence that religion is superstitious and gods are imaginary? In order to be confident in that claim, one must have infinite knowledge of all there is. We have only begun to scratch the surface on what really is real. Wars and bigotry are caused by people, not religion.

      Delete
    2. "Where is your evidence that religion is superstitious and gods are imaginary?" Where is your evidence they aren't? "Wars and bigotry are caused by people, not religion." People who are often trying to impose their way of life, often in the form of Religion, other another group of people.

      Delete
    3. "Why waste cognitive resources contemplating a supposed figment of the imagination?" To prevent thing like forced religious conversion the Catholics have been so fond of, historically, for one. To stop the teaching of religiously-backed lies in public schools in the United States, for another. Third, to fight the social conservatives who insist they should have a say in who has sex with whom and how, and weather or not women should be forced to carry every pregnancy to term, and weather it's alright to say "poop" on TV or some such nonsense. (Yes, I'm aware that liberals have supported P.C. speech, but they're not alone in that misstep.)

      Delete
    4. The evidence is found when one traces the origin of said religion or gods. It is not a complicated matter. There is no evidence of your claims regarding religion and war. It is hyperbolic rhetoric.


      What you describe will not stop conversion. Contemplating God and going after religion will just make religion more noticeable.

      Delete
  2. Maybe because of all the people who have been and still are killed in the name of religion, apply the above to racism and you will understand what I mean

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. People are killed in the name of politics and just for the heck of killing. People kill people, not religion.

      Delete
  3. I think this may be a slight misunderstanding. Atheists care about truth, and have an interest in this reality we live in. This natural leads them to bump up against the idea of gods at some point or another.

    It's interesting to note, I think, that atheists don't really care what is true so long as it actually is true. For example if gods appeared to exist then atheists would be theists. The same does not appear to be true of theists, who care more about what you believe than whether it is actually true. Ask an atheist if there was irrefutable proof of god if they would remain atheist and most will say no. Ask a theist the inverse and they will often say "I'd continue to believe because Jesus said this would happen" or something. Only one side is being honest.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well if you see the atheism hashtag on twitter you will noticed the fixation with God. This is what I question. Why dedicate so much time to a supposed "myth?"

      Delete
  4. I can't speak for all the atheists. "Atheists" is a huge set of people. All they have in common is that they don't believe a god exists. Most atheists don't even bother talking about god. They just live their lives as if no god exists. They don't take part in discussions, don't read the scriptures, don't run blogs.

    A minority of atheists do get involved. But you're wrong in saying that they care about god. They don't. You can't care about something that you don't believe exists. Rather, what they care about is the fact that religion has managed to fool so many people, to drag them away from rational thought and to make them compromise morality and decency for ancient and primitive beliefs.

    BTW, I think it really is time you stop posting nonsense about atheism (you don't seem to understand the first thing about atheism, starting with its very definition) and start proving god. The minute you prove god exists, you'll succeed against atheism. And not a second before.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "Most atheists don't even bother talking about god." Well, I have noticed the complete opposite. Every blog, every twitter account associated with atheism is focused on diatribe against God and religion, not humanism or promotion of human values and ideas.

      Delete
  5. Not all atheists are, think of it like veganism/vegetarianism, most wont mention it until you invite them to your barbecue others will actively try to explain that what you are doing is wrong.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is different. Vegetarianism doesn't have Sunday schools or shapes morals.

      Delete

Thank you for reading and for your comment. All comments are subject to approval. They must be free of vulgarity, ad hominem and must be relevant to the blog posting subject matter.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Thank you for reading and for your comment. Please be patient if you posted a comment. Spammers and other people who hide under "anonymous" sometimes post vulgar or nonsensical comments that I cannot post for obvious reasons. If your comment pertains to the posting and is free of ad hominem and vulgarity, rest assured it will be posted.

Translate

Sacerdotus Radio

Find Additional Christianity Podcasts with Sacerdotus on BlogTalkRadio